Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Theophilus's avatar

It should be “Why God condemns” or “Why the Bible condemns”. The church as no authority that is not given to it by God or the Word of God. Right?

Adam Reith's avatar

This is nonsensical.

You wrote: "Deep down, there is a subconscious understanding that sex is for uniting people and begetting children."

Human beings have no innate knowledge about any form of sexual expression.

Many young children discover masturbation on their own and are unlikely to link it to other people or making babies until told so by adults. Many societies are entirely free of silly Christian ideas about certain forms of sexual being against "natural law". Plenty of animals masturbate and engage in oral and/or gay sex. These activities would seem to be perfectly natural.

If the mouth is intended for breathing, eating, and speaking then kissing, chewing gum, and wine-tasting should count as forbidden perverted use of the mouth. If breasts are intended only for beast-feeding then fondling and kissing a woman's breasts should count as a perversion.

God could have easily designed us so that no sexual activity was pleasurable other than intercourse with a fertile woman. But masturbation is pleasurable, oral and anal sex are pleasurable, gay sex is pleasurable, and women still enjoy sex when they are temporarily or permanently infertile, and plenty of men and women enjoy sex with infertile women. It's hard not to think that God, if he exists, wants us to have lots of non-procreative sex.

The following passage is from a Catholic website: https://www.catechism.cc/articles/church-teaching-oral-sex.htm. How can any reasonably intelligent adult take this stuff seriously?

Pope Pius XII taught that it is gravely immoral for the husband, nor the wife do perform any sexual act to climax, outside of the natural marital act. The wife may not perform oral sex (fellatio) on her husband to climax. The husband may not perform oral sex on his wife to climax. In both cases, the couple sin gravely.

"By the force of this law of nature, the human person does not possess the right and power to the full exercise of the sexual faculty, directly intended, except when he performs the conjugal act according to the norms defined and imposed by nature itself. Outside of this natural act, it is not even given within the matrimonial right itself to enjoy this sexual faculty fully. These are the limits to the particular right of which we are speaking, and they circumscribe its use according to nature....."

"What has been said up to this point concerning the intrinsic evil of any full use of the generative power outside the natural conjugal act applies in the same way when the acts are of married persons or of unmarried persons, whether the full exercise of the genital organs is done by the man or the woman, or by both parties acting together; whether it is done by manual touches or by the interruption of the conjugal act; for this is always an act contrary to nature and intrinsically evil." [Pope Pius XII, Address to the Second World Congress on Fertility and Sterility, 19 May 1956]

6 more comments...

Ready for more?