Had a conversion to a new "born-again." She's in her late 60s or 70s, born again for 4 years now. It's the "Praise the Lord." "The Lord told me..." "Spirit led me..."
Me: Why'd you convert?
Her: I was into reiki and didn't know who I was praying to, I met someone who was glowing and I asked her and that's how I got to the church.
Me: Oh.
Then I told her I was a born-again; I became one when I was 17.... I thought I'd never convert to Catholicism...
So many divisions in Protestants.
Her: Oh but that's Satan.
Then she started with The Saints are dead and the Blessed Mother, and I stopped her.
You are in a false dichotomy...Catholics and Protestants can both be correct in Dogma and Wrong in Dogma...since Dogma and teachings are so broad...they can be completely wrong in one area of the teachings...
Have been Protestant all 50 years of my life. Grew up being told how horrible Catholics were. Tired of that divisive talk. Attending first Mass this week. Feeling hopeful!
I used to be a Calvinist, and if I put my old Calvinist hat back on for a moment, I suspect this is roughly how I would have answered your article then. Just to be clear: this is no longer where I stand today, but I thought it might be interesting to give you the answer from inside that framework.
A Calvinist would agree that Christ founded a real, visible Church, but would not identify that Church with one worldwide institution. They would point to local congregations with elders, preaching, baptism, the Lord’s Supper and discipline, while still saying that “Christ is the head of the church” (Col. 1:18).
On continuity, they would probably say that Christ never lost His Church, even when parts of the visible Church became seriously corrupt. Acts 20:30 would matter here: “From among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things.” So corruption inside the visible Church would not, in their view, mean that Christ’s promise had failed.
The same goes for Jesus’ words, “I am with you always, to the end of the age” (Matt. 28:20). A Calvinist would understand that as Christ preserving His people and His gospel, not as a guarantee that one particular institution could never fall into serious error.
And with the canon, the answer would be that the Church did not give Scripture its authority, but recognized the books that were already God’s Word.
Having lived inside Calvinism for many years, I thought it might be useful to show how someone from that tradition would probably answer some of your questions.
The best point in this post for me was the fact that people used to be unified under the one true Church, which was an unbroken line of apostolic succession. The Reformation was a theological disaster that fractured this unity to form thousands of denominations that disagree with each other. I have an article on how the Reformation Was a Catastrophe at https://romaredibit.com/the-reformation-was-a-catastrophe/
The doctrine of the invisible church has its' basis in scripture, but also in the teaching of election. Catholic Answers, Joel S. Peters, has a bigger problem because passages like John 6:44, John 8:47, John 10:26, and the like do not spell out a neat view of church membership.
The Jews overwhelmingly rejected Christ, and without election, the reasons do not make a lick of sense. And if we do take election into account, that would also mean that visible institutions do not reflect the heavenly realities.
Yiu indicated that the "invisible church" has its basis in Scripture. Could you please cite the Book, cgapter, and verse in Scripture where the "invisible church" is referenced?
Well, none of those verses describe the "hidden church." And the doctrine of election is inconsistent with the creation of Man with free will (likely the "manner" in which we are created in God's image), and is also inconsistent with the idea that God desires all to be saved. So, there may be a "hidden church," but it is NOT the Church that Jesus founded, and no one is going to be saved through your hidden church.
I think Protestantism has done as much damage as Catholicism post - reformation. A dog always returns to his vomit. I would just ask, aside from these questions, has the papacy brought Glory to God? It’s rhetorical and I would say absolutely not. Don’t know how any Catholic would even try to defend that. That’s the problem with the ‘institution’. Sorry, that’s never been the intention for the Body of Christ, our Lord’s bride. That’s why He predicted the fall of the temple. That system was about to be shredded. I could go on and on; doesn’t even begin to scratch the surface. Worship is not about a mortal man, Mary, Buildings or wafers.
I will make this simple from another angle. Israel as a nation and chosen people group will be restored. You would probably categorically reject that. I’m obviously not catholic and do not believe the Vatican or the Papacy represent the true church. Sorry. That is a Pharisaical representation. Yet I’m incoherent and in contempt? Contempt of what? I think my point is plain and direct. I’m not a writer, nor a typer, just a ditch digger. Saved by the Grace of God. I reject the ‘Eucharist’ as you practice in Mass. I’m sure you can give me a long dissertation of how the Reformers were wrong and an anathema. No amount of
intellectualism will
deter my view of what is truly apostate; the existence of Rome and any revised empire that will come or is now already to in place. And the Vatican may only
be part of that. Just research your own church’s history. Again, I will respectfully disagree with your foundational doctrine. The Rock is Christ. Not Peter
In many ways, Protestantism is a pretense of Catholicism, defined more by ego and proclivities than anything else. The contempt for the papacy really perplexes me.
Nearly every Protestant division has devised some sort of contrivance to ape the Bishop of Rome, whether it is the head of a denominational organization or a congregation. The difference is that the various flavors go to various lengths to preserve the egos of adherents, and the natural outcome of that is continual ruptures, because ultimately, it rests on a foundation of every man doing what is right in his own eyes. So now, at least in the West, we have entire divisions of “Christians” whose evangelism of the “faith” openly mocks Christianity with contempt.
Thank you for that. And per my post, I actually agree with your proposed points, for the most part. Because of your own ideological theology, I will leave you perplexed on my views of the papacy. Point in short; this entire spiritual journey is about Christ, The Father and Holy Spirit. And Him alone. Nothing more, nothing less. I’m not catholic, I’m not protestant. I’m a follower of Christ, The Messiah. Yeshua Hamashiach.
I certainly concur with your last statement. Ultimately, is Christ the head, or is man?
With due respect, I see both contempt and incoherency in your original comment and this one. Either you take Christ at his word or you don't. Your approach would put you outside the new covenant.
Christ said that if you love him, you will abide by his commandments. John 3 and John 6 both point explicitly to participation in the new covenant. Christ says that he came not to abolish the law, but to fulfill it. He came to establish the Church as the Body of Christ, and there is no good faith contest as to what the Church is. It is also part and parcel to the new covenant. Christ commissioned Peter as the prime minister/vicar/vizier of the Church. It's the office, not the word that matters, and the unity of the Church Christ established flows through that office. The Pope is a visual sign of unity and communion in the Church.
The entire book of Exodus is about the right worship of God. Exodus 12 lays out the Passover, and Paul identifies Christ as the New Passover. Baptism replaces circumcision, a sign of membership in the covenant. It makes us adopted sons and daughters in the household of the Father in the kingdom of heaven. It also makes a member of the Body of Christ, redeemable as a first-born son, spared from death. But the sacrifice of the Passover wasn't complete until every member of the household had partaken of at least an olive-sized portion for the victim. We do this in the Eucharist. And we are redeemed in the Ascension, when our human nature is taken up into the communion of the Trinity.
By the way, you might not like the word Catholic, but it is essentially just a synonym for the Church that Christ said he came to establish.
Poor Protestants. I was one.
Had a conversion to a new "born-again." She's in her late 60s or 70s, born again for 4 years now. It's the "Praise the Lord." "The Lord told me..." "Spirit led me..."
Me: Why'd you convert?
Her: I was into reiki and didn't know who I was praying to, I met someone who was glowing and I asked her and that's how I got to the church.
Me: Oh.
Then I told her I was a born-again; I became one when I was 17.... I thought I'd never convert to Catholicism...
So many divisions in Protestants.
Her: Oh but that's Satan.
Then she started with The Saints are dead and the Blessed Mother, and I stopped her.
You don't say that to a Catholic.
Her: I believe I'm a saint.
Me: I know.
UGH!
You are in a false dichotomy...Catholics and Protestants can both be correct in Dogma and Wrong in Dogma...since Dogma and teachings are so broad...they can be completely wrong in one area of the teachings...
Thank you Joel, this is a really solid list of arguments.
I am not protesting anyone.
Have been Protestant all 50 years of my life. Grew up being told how horrible Catholics were. Tired of that divisive talk. Attending first Mass this week. Feeling hopeful!
I used to be a Calvinist, and if I put my old Calvinist hat back on for a moment, I suspect this is roughly how I would have answered your article then. Just to be clear: this is no longer where I stand today, but I thought it might be interesting to give you the answer from inside that framework.
A Calvinist would agree that Christ founded a real, visible Church, but would not identify that Church with one worldwide institution. They would point to local congregations with elders, preaching, baptism, the Lord’s Supper and discipline, while still saying that “Christ is the head of the church” (Col. 1:18).
On continuity, they would probably say that Christ never lost His Church, even when parts of the visible Church became seriously corrupt. Acts 20:30 would matter here: “From among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things.” So corruption inside the visible Church would not, in their view, mean that Christ’s promise had failed.
The same goes for Jesus’ words, “I am with you always, to the end of the age” (Matt. 28:20). A Calvinist would understand that as Christ preserving His people and His gospel, not as a guarantee that one particular institution could never fall into serious error.
And with the canon, the answer would be that the Church did not give Scripture its authority, but recognized the books that were already God’s Word.
Having lived inside Calvinism for many years, I thought it might be useful to show how someone from that tradition would probably answer some of your questions.
The best point in this post for me was the fact that people used to be unified under the one true Church, which was an unbroken line of apostolic succession. The Reformation was a theological disaster that fractured this unity to form thousands of denominations that disagree with each other. I have an article on how the Reformation Was a Catastrophe at https://romaredibit.com/the-reformation-was-a-catastrophe/
The doctrine of the invisible church has its' basis in scripture, but also in the teaching of election. Catholic Answers, Joel S. Peters, has a bigger problem because passages like John 6:44, John 8:47, John 10:26, and the like do not spell out a neat view of church membership.
The Jews overwhelmingly rejected Christ, and without election, the reasons do not make a lick of sense. And if we do take election into account, that would also mean that visible institutions do not reflect the heavenly realities.
Thus proving the invisible church.
Yiu indicated that the "invisible church" has its basis in Scripture. Could you please cite the Book, cgapter, and verse in Scripture where the "invisible church" is referenced?
John 6:44-47, 8:47, 10:26, 12:37-43. Romans 8-9, Galatians 4:21-31, etc.
Well, none of those verses describe the "hidden church." And the doctrine of election is inconsistent with the creation of Man with free will (likely the "manner" in which we are created in God's image), and is also inconsistent with the idea that God desires all to be saved. So, there may be a "hidden church," but it is NOT the Church that Jesus founded, and no one is going to be saved through your hidden church.
So you're calling Jesus and Paul a liar, right?
Are we even going to discuss the text or pretend these verses pose no direct problem?
That's not good theology.
I think Protestantism has done as much damage as Catholicism post - reformation. A dog always returns to his vomit. I would just ask, aside from these questions, has the papacy brought Glory to God? It’s rhetorical and I would say absolutely not. Don’t know how any Catholic would even try to defend that. That’s the problem with the ‘institution’. Sorry, that’s never been the intention for the Body of Christ, our Lord’s bride. That’s why He predicted the fall of the temple. That system was about to be shredded. I could go on and on; doesn’t even begin to scratch the surface. Worship is not about a mortal man, Mary, Buildings or wafers.
Wow you seem like an absolute blast at parties.
I will make this simple from another angle. Israel as a nation and chosen people group will be restored. You would probably categorically reject that. I’m obviously not catholic and do not believe the Vatican or the Papacy represent the true church. Sorry. That is a Pharisaical representation. Yet I’m incoherent and in contempt? Contempt of what? I think my point is plain and direct. I’m not a writer, nor a typer, just a ditch digger. Saved by the Grace of God. I reject the ‘Eucharist’ as you practice in Mass. I’m sure you can give me a long dissertation of how the Reformers were wrong and an anathema. No amount of
intellectualism will
deter my view of what is truly apostate; the existence of Rome and any revised empire that will come or is now already to in place. And the Vatican may only
be part of that. Just research your own church’s history. Again, I will respectfully disagree with your foundational doctrine. The Rock is Christ. Not Peter
In many ways, Protestantism is a pretense of Catholicism, defined more by ego and proclivities than anything else. The contempt for the papacy really perplexes me.
Nearly every Protestant division has devised some sort of contrivance to ape the Bishop of Rome, whether it is the head of a denominational organization or a congregation. The difference is that the various flavors go to various lengths to preserve the egos of adherents, and the natural outcome of that is continual ruptures, because ultimately, it rests on a foundation of every man doing what is right in his own eyes. So now, at least in the West, we have entire divisions of “Christians” whose evangelism of the “faith” openly mocks Christianity with contempt.
Thank you for that. And per my post, I actually agree with your proposed points, for the most part. Because of your own ideological theology, I will leave you perplexed on my views of the papacy. Point in short; this entire spiritual journey is about Christ, The Father and Holy Spirit. And Him alone. Nothing more, nothing less. I’m not catholic, I’m not protestant. I’m a follower of Christ, The Messiah. Yeshua Hamashiach.
I certainly concur with your last statement. Ultimately, is Christ the head, or is man?
With due respect, I see both contempt and incoherency in your original comment and this one. Either you take Christ at his word or you don't. Your approach would put you outside the new covenant.
Christ said that if you love him, you will abide by his commandments. John 3 and John 6 both point explicitly to participation in the new covenant. Christ says that he came not to abolish the law, but to fulfill it. He came to establish the Church as the Body of Christ, and there is no good faith contest as to what the Church is. It is also part and parcel to the new covenant. Christ commissioned Peter as the prime minister/vicar/vizier of the Church. It's the office, not the word that matters, and the unity of the Church Christ established flows through that office. The Pope is a visual sign of unity and communion in the Church.
The entire book of Exodus is about the right worship of God. Exodus 12 lays out the Passover, and Paul identifies Christ as the New Passover. Baptism replaces circumcision, a sign of membership in the covenant. It makes us adopted sons and daughters in the household of the Father in the kingdom of heaven. It also makes a member of the Body of Christ, redeemable as a first-born son, spared from death. But the sacrifice of the Passover wasn't complete until every member of the household had partaken of at least an olive-sized portion for the victim. We do this in the Eucharist. And we are redeemed in the Ascension, when our human nature is taken up into the communion of the Trinity.
By the way, you might not like the word Catholic, but it is essentially just a synonym for the Church that Christ said he came to establish.