Long time CA supporter here, curious why Trent is no longer with y’all? He did so much to bring me to the faith and I love CA as an organization, just hoping for some clarity on this
Two words shine in your really good post. "Substitutionary atonement" . Christians are saved due to Christ's righteousness being seen by our Father instead of our lack of righteousness. Christ being the only righteous "person" to have ever walked this earth.
I don’t understand why our Orthdox brothers and sisters sometimes think we are too legal minded. It seems we have far more overlap of God healing and unifying us with him in atonement theology and soteriology.
I think that your critique of Penal Substitution cannot in principle anathematize an illustrious doctor like the holy and illustrious Gallican Bishop Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet
Quoting the post's quote: “'Is God the Father so ruthless that someone must necessarily suffer the punishment for sin, and if it is not the sinner himself, then it can (must?) be his beloved Son?'” This is a cold, ruthless form of justice, in which God simultaneously loves and hates."
This would be cold and ruthless if God were not triune. But the Father and Son are one, so when the Father punishes the Son, God is taking the punishment for human sin upon himself. Greater love has no man than he who lays down his life for his friends.
Interesting argument. The point that "sin" can mean "sin offering" in the Old Testament is a good reminder that how a word is used in its own setting shapes how we read a verse. I take a similar approach to John's use of "antichrist," which I wrote about here: https://drbencarsonodongo.substack.com/p/the-antichrist-john-actually-wrote
Long time CA supporter here, curious why Trent is no longer with y’all? He did so much to bring me to the faith and I love CA as an organization, just hoping for some clarity on this
Weird how they’re so quiet about this. Something’s fishy here.
Two words shine in your really good post. "Substitutionary atonement" . Christians are saved due to Christ's righteousness being seen by our Father instead of our lack of righteousness. Christ being the only righteous "person" to have ever walked this earth.
I don’t understand why our Orthdox brothers and sisters sometimes think we are too legal minded. It seems we have far more overlap of God healing and unifying us with him in atonement theology and soteriology.
I think that your critique of Penal Substitution cannot in principle anathematize an illustrious doctor like the holy and illustrious Gallican Bishop Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet
Quoting the post's quote: “'Is God the Father so ruthless that someone must necessarily suffer the punishment for sin, and if it is not the sinner himself, then it can (must?) be his beloved Son?'” This is a cold, ruthless form of justice, in which God simultaneously loves and hates."
This would be cold and ruthless if God were not triune. But the Father and Son are one, so when the Father punishes the Son, God is taking the punishment for human sin upon himself. Greater love has no man than he who lays down his life for his friends.
So sorry for you.
Interesting argument. The point that "sin" can mean "sin offering" in the Old Testament is a good reminder that how a word is used in its own setting shapes how we read a verse. I take a similar approach to John's use of "antichrist," which I wrote about here: https://drbencarsonodongo.substack.com/p/the-antichrist-john-actually-wrote