51 Comments
User's avatar
Matt's avatar

When is this guy ever going to get properly admonished by the hierarchy of our Church? We're all tired of seeing the wrong people get promoted and repeatedly allowed to cause scandal. We need to do more

Matt's avatar

By this guy I mean Fr Martin of course. He's almost like a soft, leftist spokesperson for celebrities to talk to.

David Stevens's avatar

Haven’t followed him for awhile but this is objectionable at best.

Queer “theory” aside, as the article suggests, the confession rewrite is personal happiness centered not God centered.

Time to draw a line.

Jabob Beppler's avatar

Every day that he goes undisciplined while Traditiones Custodes stands, continues to drain massive amounts of credibility from Christ’s Church.

What prelate has the courage?

JJ's avatar

🙏🏻… pray for us sinners , now and at the hour of our death

KB’s Musings & Observations's avatar

Twisted evil twaddle. Why isn’t this man excommunicated?

Lisa Tritico's avatar

Ok I’m gay and a practicing Catholic. That whole thing is so self serving. It’s all verbal and mental gymnastics. Get over yourself. You’re Catholic. These are the rules. Go to confession and get on with it.

The Letters of John Hexham's avatar

Holy Moley!! Time to re-read John 8…

Nicholas M's avatar

I read Fr. Martin's book, Building a Bridge and if I remember correctly he never says or suggests that homosexual acts are a true and moral expression of human sexuality. I don't know about this organization and who works for it, how solid their catechetical basis is, but Fr. Martin's point was cautiously put as the Church is for everyone and the Church must address and minister to everyone. There are not only two choices: maintain orthodoxy or shift with the times. There are three: misunderstand the Church by treating it like a private club that does not call out to a certain type of sinner for fear we may encounter them; misunderstand the Church as a private club directed by the whims of the majority; understand the Church correctly as the body of Christ that is in the world (addressing all people) but not of the world (calling all people to repentance away from all sins, however “natural” they might seem in our sinful state).

John's avatar

The church has maintained orthodoxy, so far, based on scripture and tradition (not the whims of the majority) and has reached out to sinners, not by redefining our sins. See Courage International.

Matt's avatar

The very fact he uses secular terminology like "queer Catholics" and "trans Catholics" tells us everything. He believes these are not sinful inclinations, nor an intrinsic part of who we are but something that is an important and innate part of their being. This isn't his first scandal and will not be his last. Also you should know there is a very big difference between what he published officially as a clergyman and what he says and participates in. We are CATHOLIC not nit Trans Catholic, jist as someone who struggles with masterbation wouldn't call themselves a "masterbater Catholic and part of the lustful community".

Nicholas M's avatar

Desires are not sinful unless both of these conditions are met: (1) they are directed toward sinful acts; and (2) the person dwells on the desire and does not resist it. We all have involuntary desires, including sexual ones that should not be indulged in. If you are married, you should not indulge in sexual desires for a woman other than your wife. If a thought of another woman involuntarily enters your mind (and we all know this happens all the time) it is not a sin unless you dwell on it, seek out occasions to arouse this desire, etc. If we extrapolate this principle to homosexuals (where the desires are in principle ordered toward sinful acts) they are not guilty for desires that arise involuntarily unless they dwell on them. And there is no problem with phrases like “gay Catholics.” There are Catholics who are liars, adulterers, thieves and murderers. These are sins but they do not erase a person's Catholicism. They make the person in even greater need of the Church and of confession. That is why the Church must minister to these people. As far as I have read, that is what Fr. Martin is saying.

Matt's avatar

Nor possibly just an intrinsic part*

Kimmie P's avatar

you got it all wrong friend, you have free will, I have free will, we all have free will, A priest’s role is to offer sacrifice, not massage your feelings. Sirach 15:16-18. “Before you is fire and water; therefore, stretch out your hand, make your choice and it will be given to you. “ We all struggle mightily turning away from sin daily. Everyone has their cross to bear. Jesus Christ himself tells us if we want to be his disciple we have to deny ourselves,

full stop, pick up our cross and follow him.

Nicholas M's avatar

If this is a response to me then I'm not following what you are saying.

Lou Rosas's avatar

Ya, no...I will trust the science over the superstition...

Sweet Marty's avatar

Total garbage…

Alessia V's avatar

I can understand why Fr. Martin is doing what he’s doing, but he is stepping over the line. Changing the Confiteor I definitely do not agree with. That’s something I think a protestant would do lol. We must accept the rules of the Catholic Church, whether we agree with them or not. Look what happened to others who tried to change them fit their own beliefs (if you don’t know, it’s excommunication).

However, I do not agree that the LGBTQ community is some sort of evil Satan cult and they deserved to be disrespected. I just see them as fellow sheep that have been led astray. They are sinners just like us and they deserve the same respect and dignity that all humans deserve. We must love the sinner, not the sin.

When Jesus was with prostitutes and tax collectors, he treated them with respect in hopes of them repenting and believing. Therefore we must treat all sinners the same, no matter how grave the sin. People who are part of the LGBTQ community have not just been led astray, but also, unfortunately, pushed away by members of the Catholic Church, and that is not gonna help them come back to the Church.

All we need to do is help them understand that committing homosexual acts is not natural and is therefore against how God made us. They must repent and they can choose whether to be chaste or marry someone of the opposite sex. Let us pray for these people in hopes that they will see the mercy of God!

James's avatar

Dante would have a good idea about Martin’s ultimate fate.

Jed Brown's avatar

“The Pope succeeds Peter only in his denial of Christ." -Thomas Watson

Jack Ditch's avatar

I pray to the Lord to forgive both the fool who would deny me, as a gay man, the words to be properly contrite for all my sins, and also the fool who would deny the sanctity of my marriage to my husband, the most loving, Christlike relationship I have known.

For we all fall short of the cross.

Charlaine Andrulot's avatar

More than “ falling short”!

Paul in the New Testament definitely state that man should not lie within other men

He also says women should not not perform sexual acts with other women!

Jack Ditch's avatar

He also says love keeps no record of wrongs.

Charlaine Andrulot's avatar

Wait until Jesus comes back..judgement is Gods not any one else!

Lou Rosas's avatar

Homosexuality is not a "condition" like kleptomania or other disorders or conditions...it is how the person is born--it literally is how God made that person...so, Ratzinger was incorrect in this point...

As a Cradle Catholic, I was taught to separate the existential nature vs the behavioral nature: being vs. acting...based on this, there is no sin in being homosexual, no more than it is wrong being left handed, or being a person with brown hair, or 6'6"...just like there is no sin in being heterosexual...the sin come in the action--the behavior...acting homosexual is considered to be a sin in part because sex is reserved in marriage and marriage is reserved between a man and a woman...

It is time you listened more closely to the science: and the science has spoken in regards to this...thankfully so, a homosexual cannot be "cured" (it is not a disease)...

Prophet Des Höchsten's avatar

God does not seduce to mortal sin. Satan does. Sodomy is a sin Jesus hates. Stop it with your nonsense. Scripture and Catechism are very clear. Also search for Saint Peter Damian’s take on homosexuality.

Lou Rosas's avatar

This is not nonsense...it is reality...sexual sin must have action...

Ergo, being is not a sin...

Hearing the takes on saints when it comes to issues of science is not accurate--I do not care what St Damian nor any other saint has to say about this anymore than I care to know what saints held dogmatic insistence of a geo-centric universe...

And, I will remind you every time the Church goes up against science it gets its ass handed to it (mainly by a bunch of physicists, but this time by biologists and psychologists)...

Prophet Des Höchsten's avatar

Science? Mortal sin leads to eternal damnation in hell. That is the teaching. And sodomy is a disorder run by demons of lust that Jesus can deliver a person from. Jesus exorcises demons. That is the true science, revelations of God Almighty.

Lou Rosas's avatar

Again, you are reaffirming the fact the sin is not in being, but acting...a person can a homosexual not engaged in sodomy and is not committing a sin in the same way a person can be heterosexual not engaged in sexual act and not commit a sin...

Yes, science is evidence based and thus is to be accepted (unless you would like to chose not to believe in gravity)...and the evidence through scientific rigor shows that homosexuals are born, like heterosexuals are born, like left-handers are born, like short people are born...etc...etc...

DramaMama's avatar

Jesuit Moral Theologian friend in 1980’s = is not sinful have homosexual inclinations but must FIGHT it not PRACTICE it. Marital Union ONLY for lawfully married man & woman with the intent to be open for conception every time, everything else = sinful. Psychiatrist on EWTN & on Vatican commission stated many gays lacked a father who modeled guy behaviors - roughhousing, playing ball... Lack of love, guidance, attention etc. messes up identity, self concept. Scripture says: If a man looks at a woman with lustful thoughts, that’s sinful so anyone can sin without performing the act itself.

Lou Rosas's avatar

Yes...the Jesuit moral theologian is mirroring exactly what is taught...sex is reserved for marriage, marriage is reserved for a man and a woman (restated from my statements above)...and that resistance applies to all unmarried persons, regardless of sexual orientation...the psychiatrist sounds suspect--since homosexuality was removed from the list of disorders in 1972 (and understanding has improved)...based on his logic, practically every male that grew up with a father would be homosexual--that is no where near the case and has less to do with sexual orientation and more to do with behavior...there are homosexuals that came from all types of families--just like heterosexuals--near perfect families to incredible dysfunctional families...sounds like this guy was pandering to EWTN...

Prophet Des Höchsten's avatar

It is a disorder. Don’t listen to secular sorcerers like psychologists who do not have the Holy Spirit, and who are trying to convince you it is not a disorder. Their false science based on data is similar to how one can measure any prevalence of any disorder and then say that this is just a personality type. It ignores the spiritual battle we are living in and also how living in a state of grace, by being a good practicing and confessed Catholic, helps us to be protected from demons and their influences.

You are right these demons can infest anyone who let their guard down and can’t attribute it to family situations or genes. The Devil goes around to see who he can devour and seduce to sickly behavior like homosexuality.

1 Peter 5:8-11

8 Be sober, be vigilant; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour: 9 Whom resist stedfast in the faith, knowing that the same afflictions are accomplished in your brethren that are in the world. 10 But the God of all grace, who hath called us unto his eternal glory by Christ Jesus, after that ye have suffered a while, make you perfect, stablish, strengthen, settle you. 11 To him be glory and dominion for ever and ever. Amen.

Lou Rosas's avatar

ya...no...I will trust the science over the superstition...

Lou Rosas's avatar

I would rather have questions that cannot be answered than answers that can't be questioned...

-Dr. Richard Feynman