Pope Pius XII taught that it is gravely immoral for the husband, nor the wife do perform any sexual act to climax, outside of the natural marital act. The wife may not perform oral sex (fellatio) on her husband to climax. The husband may not perform oral sex on his wife to climax. In both cases, the couple sin gravely.
"By the force of this law of nature, the human person does not possess the right and power to the full exercise of the sexual faculty, directly intended, except when he performs the conjugal act according to the norms defined and imposed by nature itself. Outside of this natural act, it is not even given within the matrimonial right itself to enjoy this sexual faculty fully. These are the limits to the particular right of which we are speaking, and they circumscribe its use according to nature....."
"What has been said up to this point concerning the intrinsic evil of any full use of the generative power outside the natural conjugal act applies in the same way when the acts are of married persons or of unmarried persons, whether the full exercise of the genital organs is done by the man or the woman, or by both parties acting together; whether it is done by manual touches or by the interruption of the conjugal act; for this is always an act contrary to nature and intrinsically evil." [Pope Pius XII, Address to the Second World Congress on Fertility and Sterility, 19 May 1956]
We need more Catholic content creators to talk about this and sexual ethics in general. There is so much confusion out there as to what is allowed in the marriage bed.
Once again, this is where an organization interludes into science, and once again, that organization is continuing to get its ass handed to it...this time, by psychologists...the first and foremost thing is to follow the science--and there is plenty of science out there that debunks #1...you just continue to harp on it because it is not staring you in the face like the Galileo ass handing (which, by the way was debunked by Newton)...
The post implies the science is wrong...and that is not true...just because it conflicts with morality does not make the science incorrect...in fact, the science concludes masturbation is healthy *and* normal with many physical and mental benefits...
No it isn’t? Its saying although the science is correct about stress relief and other such psychological benefits of masturbation, that does not make it a moral act. A sadist would find stress relief in causing the suffering of another, does that make it moral? Obviously not. To argue that masturbation is immoral is obviously much harder than saying torture is morally wrong. However this post is applying Catholic teaching to the topic of masturbation and saying in spite of the benefits you probably shouldn’t if you care about your salvation. I feel you have misunderstood quite a bit.
stop the false equivalency in comparing sadism to a non-sadistic act...the and indeed masturbation is healthy and normal...as far as the moral act, the morality that encourages avoiding something the science determines is healthy and indeed normal should cause pause in all people--because that sounds like a rather sadistic position...
Modern psychology views masturbation as a normal, healthy, and natural human behavior that serves physical, emotional, and cognitive functions.
Key Psychological Perspectives on Masturbation
• Stress and Emotion Regulation: Masturbation releases neurochemicals like dopamine, endorphins, oxytocin, and serotonin, which lower cortisol (stress hormones), reduce anxiety, and promote relaxation. Many people use it as a self-soothing or coping mechanism to manage boredom, tension, or emotional distress.
• Sexual Self-Knowledge and Confidence: It allows individuals to explore their own anatomy, discover what brings them pleasure, and understand their personal sexual responses. This self-awareness often translates into better communication and higher satisfaction in partnered relationships.
• Impact on Partnered Relationships: Psychology largely rejects the old myth that masturbation harms romantic or sexual relationships. Instead, it can act as a complement to a shared sex life, help bridge differences in high vs. low sexual desire between partners, and relieve sexual pressure.
• Cognitive Focus: Short-term studies show that post-orgasm neurochemical shifts can create a sense of mental clarity, and minor cognitive tasks (like word recall) sometimes show temporary improvement right after sexual release, though it does not fundamentally alter long-term memory.
The Role of Guilt and "Moral Incongruence"
• Guilt and Shame: Negative feelings after masturbation are rarely caused by the act itself. Psychologists attribute post-masturbation distress to moral incongruence—the internal conflict that happens when a person’s natural behavior clashes with their personal, cultural, or religious upbringing.
• Ego-Dystonic Masturbation: In clinical settings, distress only becomes problematic when a person feels intensely conflicted or guilty about an otherwise normal habit (known as ego-dystonic masturbation), which is often tied to broader anxiety or depression.
When Does It Become Problematic?
Psychology and clinical classifications generally consider masturbation an issue only when it stops being a choice and becomes a compulsive sexual behavior (CSB) or an unhealthy emotional escape. This happens if:
• It interferes with daily responsibilities, work performance, or social relationships.
• It is used habitually to numb or completely avoid facing real-world emotional or relationship problems.
• It causes genuine personal distress rather than relief or pleasure.
For a comprehensive overview of how self-stimulation is viewed across behavioral and social science, explore Psychology Today's Masturbation Guide.
and the next question is: you got your PhD in psychology from where?
I just skimmed through the text and I’m going to do a deep read but I had a question: If Humane Vitae condemns contraception, even a condom with a hole is to a degree restricting the full load of seminal fluid and thus restricting Gods creative power in a way as we are designed for the full load to enter. So would this not too be sinful?
Firstly the reason for the condom isn't to prevent life but to collect a sample and secondly because it has holes it is allowing the chance of life to happen. The reason why something is done is very important.
While I agree the intent here is important and not overtly malicious, it still prevents the full load entry. Thus the proper amount of semen that should enter the vagina for possible conception is not complete and Gods creative power is restricted. I find it much more fitting to complete the marital act and swab the penis for excess semen and test that sample, rather than the brunt of the load captured within a condom. (Albeit one with a hole)
And as an Edit here I’m going to add a possible objection:
“Well if there’s still a possibility of life here then if God really willed contraception in this case he would bring it about despite the lacking of a full load”
Are we not told in the scriptures to not put the Lord our God to the test? Following through with this course of action is almost as if one is testing Gods will for conception especially in the case of someone already doubting their reproductive potency.
Very true but maybe a swab doesn't give enough of a sample for testing (I'm not a doctor so cannot speak to it). However we should not dismiss the reason why so easily after all it is the difference between someone being sentenced for manslaughter or murder.
Yes I do see a genuine intended will of good on behalf of the condom argument. Humane Vitae however is what grounds my stubbornness on the issue. Particularly the concepts of “Gods creative power” and “divine sovereignty”.
I too am no doctor, so perhaps the swab method needs more investigation but I think we understand why eachother hold our positions well.
I appreciate your analogy of intent with murder and manslaughter here too. I will posit however that in both cases a wrong has been committed. Contraceptive sex being the murder and faulty contraceptive sex being the manslaughter. In either case contraception has been harnessed and an individual has died.
This is such bullshit, especially when you consider teenage boys or not married and have no one they can procreate with. And also for elderly, whose spouse may have died among others.
Hilarious!
More hilarity from an official Catholic website (https://www.catechism.cc/articles/church-teaching-oral-sex.htm):
Pope Pius XII taught that it is gravely immoral for the husband, nor the wife do perform any sexual act to climax, outside of the natural marital act. The wife may not perform oral sex (fellatio) on her husband to climax. The husband may not perform oral sex on his wife to climax. In both cases, the couple sin gravely.
"By the force of this law of nature, the human person does not possess the right and power to the full exercise of the sexual faculty, directly intended, except when he performs the conjugal act according to the norms defined and imposed by nature itself. Outside of this natural act, it is not even given within the matrimonial right itself to enjoy this sexual faculty fully. These are the limits to the particular right of which we are speaking, and they circumscribe its use according to nature....."
"What has been said up to this point concerning the intrinsic evil of any full use of the generative power outside the natural conjugal act applies in the same way when the acts are of married persons or of unmarried persons, whether the full exercise of the genital organs is done by the man or the woman, or by both parties acting together; whether it is done by manual touches or by the interruption of the conjugal act; for this is always an act contrary to nature and intrinsically evil." [Pope Pius XII, Address to the Second World Congress on Fertility and Sterility, 19 May 1956]
You might find this funny, but every sperm is sacred.
Shouldn’t this also imply every micro organism is also sacred?
We need more Catholic content creators to talk about this and sexual ethics in general. There is so much confusion out there as to what is allowed in the marriage bed.
No fingering your wife, that’s a sin!
Once again, this is where an organization interludes into science, and once again, that organization is continuing to get its ass handed to it...this time, by psychologists...the first and foremost thing is to follow the science--and there is plenty of science out there that debunks #1...you just continue to harp on it because it is not staring you in the face like the Galileo ass handing (which, by the way was debunked by Newton)...
I am confused on what your point is. How does this conflict with the post?
The post implies the science is wrong...and that is not true...just because it conflicts with morality does not make the science incorrect...in fact, the science concludes masturbation is healthy *and* normal with many physical and mental benefits...
No it isn’t? Its saying although the science is correct about stress relief and other such psychological benefits of masturbation, that does not make it a moral act. A sadist would find stress relief in causing the suffering of another, does that make it moral? Obviously not. To argue that masturbation is immoral is obviously much harder than saying torture is morally wrong. However this post is applying Catholic teaching to the topic of masturbation and saying in spite of the benefits you probably shouldn’t if you care about your salvation. I feel you have misunderstood quite a bit.
Are you aware that women require direct stimulation of their clitoris to climax?
Intercourse alone is insufficient for most women to reach orgasm.
stop the false equivalency in comparing sadism to a non-sadistic act...the and indeed masturbation is healthy and normal...as far as the moral act, the morality that encourages avoiding something the science determines is healthy and indeed normal should cause pause in all people--because that sounds like a rather sadistic position...
The science debunks the science that masturbation is a common human behaviour especially in sexually developing humans?
ummm...no...apparently does not...
Modern psychology views masturbation as a normal, healthy, and natural human behavior that serves physical, emotional, and cognitive functions.
Key Psychological Perspectives on Masturbation
• Stress and Emotion Regulation: Masturbation releases neurochemicals like dopamine, endorphins, oxytocin, and serotonin, which lower cortisol (stress hormones), reduce anxiety, and promote relaxation. Many people use it as a self-soothing or coping mechanism to manage boredom, tension, or emotional distress.
• Sexual Self-Knowledge and Confidence: It allows individuals to explore their own anatomy, discover what brings them pleasure, and understand their personal sexual responses. This self-awareness often translates into better communication and higher satisfaction in partnered relationships.
• Impact on Partnered Relationships: Psychology largely rejects the old myth that masturbation harms romantic or sexual relationships. Instead, it can act as a complement to a shared sex life, help bridge differences in high vs. low sexual desire between partners, and relieve sexual pressure.
• Cognitive Focus: Short-term studies show that post-orgasm neurochemical shifts can create a sense of mental clarity, and minor cognitive tasks (like word recall) sometimes show temporary improvement right after sexual release, though it does not fundamentally alter long-term memory.
The Role of Guilt and "Moral Incongruence"
• Guilt and Shame: Negative feelings after masturbation are rarely caused by the act itself. Psychologists attribute post-masturbation distress to moral incongruence—the internal conflict that happens when a person’s natural behavior clashes with their personal, cultural, or religious upbringing.
• Ego-Dystonic Masturbation: In clinical settings, distress only becomes problematic when a person feels intensely conflicted or guilty about an otherwise normal habit (known as ego-dystonic masturbation), which is often tied to broader anxiety or depression.
When Does It Become Problematic?
Psychology and clinical classifications generally consider masturbation an issue only when it stops being a choice and becomes a compulsive sexual behavior (CSB) or an unhealthy emotional escape. This happens if:
• It interferes with daily responsibilities, work performance, or social relationships.
• It is used habitually to numb or completely avoid facing real-world emotional or relationship problems.
• It causes genuine personal distress rather than relief or pleasure.
For a comprehensive overview of how self-stimulation is viewed across behavioral and social science, explore Psychology Today's Masturbation Guide.
and the next question is: you got your PhD in psychology from where?
Follow up question, you got your MD from where???
I just skimmed through the text and I’m going to do a deep read but I had a question: If Humane Vitae condemns contraception, even a condom with a hole is to a degree restricting the full load of seminal fluid and thus restricting Gods creative power in a way as we are designed for the full load to enter. So would this not too be sinful?
Firstly the reason for the condom isn't to prevent life but to collect a sample and secondly because it has holes it is allowing the chance of life to happen. The reason why something is done is very important.
While I agree the intent here is important and not overtly malicious, it still prevents the full load entry. Thus the proper amount of semen that should enter the vagina for possible conception is not complete and Gods creative power is restricted. I find it much more fitting to complete the marital act and swab the penis for excess semen and test that sample, rather than the brunt of the load captured within a condom. (Albeit one with a hole)
And as an Edit here I’m going to add a possible objection:
“Well if there’s still a possibility of life here then if God really willed contraception in this case he would bring it about despite the lacking of a full load”
Are we not told in the scriptures to not put the Lord our God to the test? Following through with this course of action is almost as if one is testing Gods will for conception especially in the case of someone already doubting their reproductive potency.
Very true but maybe a swab doesn't give enough of a sample for testing (I'm not a doctor so cannot speak to it). However we should not dismiss the reason why so easily after all it is the difference between someone being sentenced for manslaughter or murder.
Yes I do see a genuine intended will of good on behalf of the condom argument. Humane Vitae however is what grounds my stubbornness on the issue. Particularly the concepts of “Gods creative power” and “divine sovereignty”.
I too am no doctor, so perhaps the swab method needs more investigation but I think we understand why eachother hold our positions well.
I appreciate your analogy of intent with murder and manslaughter here too. I will posit however that in both cases a wrong has been committed. Contraceptive sex being the murder and faulty contraceptive sex being the manslaughter. In either case contraception has been harnessed and an individual has died.
This is such bullshit, especially when you consider teenage boys or not married and have no one they can procreate with. And also for elderly, whose spouse may have died among others.
I’m not “masturbating” I’m ~treating my hysteria~
Seriously at a time when certain folks are pursuing more interest in rhe Catholic faith and you decide to score about 100 own goals by posting this.
The testing seamen seems in conflict with the CCC.